WebLived In Palm Bay FL, Indialantic FL, Houston TX, Lyons IL. I'd stay up two or three days in a row with no sleep and even then I'd have to drink beer to calm down. Although they had a confession for the Gainesville murders, investigators were not able to get Rolling to admit to the Shreveport murders during their questioning. Mrs. Hlavaty died about 56 hours before the grand jury decided her grandson Ed should not be charged in the Gainesville murders. Rolling pleaded guilty to all counts but, because he was facing the death penalty, a jury was still required to hear the evidence and make a recommendation on punishment to the judge: life in prison or death. Authorities subsequently cleared Humphrey of any involvement in the murders. Prior to his death, he spoke to a pastor and handed him a note. "Your honor, I've been running from first one thing and then another all my life," Rolling said. The muster roll references 44 names. "And, like, they point in my face telling me, 'Don't do that again, man. The officer, now-retired Det. A television blared. WebEdward Lewis Humphrey was an early suspect in the case of five grisly murders of college students in Gainesville, Florida; one Daniel Rolling was eventually convicted of the killings, All of Gainesville shuddered. Humphrey was arrested just days after the murders and held in jail on a $1 million bond. "It didn't matter what the lyrics were or what he was saying at that point. All of them had been stabbed to death and some were left in sexually provocative positions. His court appearances were riveting. In less than five years. He was the youngest of four kids. "My mouth dropped open when he told me," she says. He drove to Orlando on a blustery fall day in a black 1978 Cadillac that gets 10 miles to the gallon. The real killer was eventually caught, confessed and was put to death. Ed answered immediately, and the two have been exchanging letters at least once a month ever since. And an odd thing happened: Agents from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement showed up and began questioning him about the murders. These days Ed Humphrey lives at home with his mom in Indialantic. He may have more plastic surgery. He'll never change his name, but some day, he says, when he's done with school, he might move somewhere far away. "The main thing is, I'm just like anybody else," he says. The murders occurred over several days, which made them all the more terrifying. Humphrey has been jailed on $1 million bond since the beating Aug. 30. ", Marti Mackenzie nods. "I can only afford to fill the tank halfway," he says, settling into a window seat at an upscale downtown restaurant. Other times it appears to happen in an instant. ), "We had a lot of physical evidence that, according to our technology at the time, placed Ed at some of the scenes," Maines said. The second, more sinister personality, was named "Gemini" and Rolling blamed him for his deadliest acts. Don Maines, an investigator on the case with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, said they received several tips pointing to Humphrey, then 18. Rolling pleaded guilty to the serial killings of five young people at the University of Florida in Gainesville.). But Public Defender J.R. Russo said today that some hospitals rejected Humphrey outright and the only ones that would admit him would charge $600 to $1,000 a day, more than the family could afford. His grandmother, Elna Hlavaty, told a deputy that night that her grandson had beaten and choked her in the familys home in Indialantic. WebDescription Muster roll for Humphrey Lewis' Company from Madison County, ca. And legal experts say that even if Humphrey is innocent, he'll carry the stigma of the killings with him the rest of his days. One woman had also been found with soap on her body and the perpetrator had used duct tape on both of the victims, but the tape had been removed. It made his mouth dry. Genetic tests conducted on pubic hairs were similar to Ed's - and about 8,000 other people in Alachua County. Once Florida investigators realized that Rolling had multiple convictions for armed robbery, they realized he could have also been responsible for the bank robbery that occurred on the day that Christa Hoyt's body was found. The next day Humphrey is reported to be running in circles and talking to himself on Patrick Air Force Base. WebEdward Lewis Humphrey is a resident of Palm Bay. At this moment he would be home in Indialantic studying for a science test--and hoping, unrealistically, that people would just forget Ed Humphrey. He also decapitated her and posed the head on a bookshelf. TITUSVILLE, Fla. (AP) _ Gainesville murder suspect Edward Lewis Humphrey was sentenced today to the maximum 22 months for beating his grandmother after his Prosecutors also attacked Rollings' claims that he had multiple personalities and that he was overtaken by his evil "Gemini" side when he murdered his victims. It worked, but it also made him dull, sluggish, overweight. Ray Barber, called for backup and with more investigators on the scene, they found Powell dead on the first floor of the apartment. On Aug. 30, Humphrey returned to his Indialantic home from Gainesville, where he had enrolled as a freshman at the University of Florida. I was like, God, I can't handle this.". Current Address: YVXK San Paulo Cir, Melbourne, Like the previous murders, Paules, who'd been raped, was found posed and she had soap on her lower body as well as tape residue on her wrists and mouth. Rolling's defense presented mitigating factors for why he might have committed the murders, including his troubled history with his father. Yet the lead prosecutor in the case continued to insist that Ed was a suspect in three of the killings, that perhaps he and Rolling had acted together. Hewitt said the man also talked to his family, about life and how he felt he went down the "wrong road." I got it done . But months passed and Humphrey was never charged with the crimes, the Alachua County grand jury deciding that there was no case against him. Do you understand that? There is still a court order not to discuss evidence m the case. "It showed a picture of him, and he seemed trustworthy but kind of crestfallen. A neighbor also reports that the grandson is running in and out of the home - shouting that he is going to murder the grandparents. His parents split up when Ed was about 11, but they didn't divorce for several years. ET on ABC. "I did that at the time because I read that serial killers like to be in control," Mario Taboada told ABC News. "I kept saying to myself, it's the last thing I can do for her. For the family members of the Gainesville victims, it was another moment in this long and heartbreaking story. Would he demand I leave? He demanded officials exonerate his brother. I mean, I was amped. ", George Humphrey says "John" was a reference to John the Apostle. Although police had collected the evidence, at the time, they did not connect the bank robbery to the student murders because a gun was found at the campsite and the murders didn't involve a gun. he would yell. Edward Lewis Humphrey was an early suspect in the case of five grisly murders of college students in Gainesville, Fla. Daniel Rolling was eventually convicted of the killings, but Humphrey was never officially cleared by the police. Without warning, Ed jumped out of the car. It was going 60 mph at the time. WebView Edward Humphrey results in Florida (FL) including current phone number, address, relatives, background check report, and property record with Whitepages. He had no reason to trust one. You could see [she was] in a bad position, and I just turned around and walked out," Curnutt said. Glenn Ruppel, Sean Dooley, and Anthony Rivas. Ed says. The way I- see it, he got the shaft when they sentenced him. Ed's bail, originally set at $10,250 was increased to $1 million - 100 to 200 times the scheduled rate for aggravated assault. ", Dianna Hoyt said she didn't believe "any of it. "The first night I was in there, no one told me anything," he says. It has been the biggest manhunt in Florida history. He called the match to the evidence in Gainesville a "revelation" in the case. WebEdward Lewis Humphrey, Age 51 aka Lewis E Humphrey, Edward J Humphrey, Humphrey Edward Lewis, Humphrey Humphrey Current Address: YVXK San Paulo Cir, Melbourne, FL Past Addresses: Palm Bay FL, Indialantic FL +5 more Phone Number: (321) 544- IQVS +7 phones Email Address: e NNQI @hotmail.com +1 email UNLOCK PROFILE Phone & Email WebLived In Honolulu HI, Morehead City NC, Orange Park FL, Saint Petersburg FL. Marker Address Rent ? She briefs him before interviews; she and his attorney decide which questions he'll answer. Danny Harold Rolling pleaded guilty to their murders and three other people in Gainesville in August 1990.). Humphreys off behavior, Mann said, drew attention to him. Hewitt said they learned that Rolling had returned to the crime scene after killing Christa Hoyt because he thought he might've left his wallet there. Edward Lewis Humphrey was an early suspect in the case of five grisly murders of college students in Gainesville, Florida; one Daniel Rolling was eventually On Wednesday, his grandmother, Elna Hlavaty, died at age 80 after suffering a heart attack in Indialantic. A jury found him guilty of one count of battery upon a person over the age of 65, a third-degree felony, and he was sentenced to 22 months in prison, plus probation. Even though three decades had passed, I knew it wasnt going to be easy for Humphrey to talk about his darkest days; a time when his name was linked to grisly crimes. Smith said Rolling also talked about the best way to kill a deer. WebEdward Lewis Humphrey, Age 51. aka Lewis E Humphrey, Edward J Humphrey, Humphrey Edward Lewis, Humphrey Humphrey. When he was arrested for hitting his grandmother and questioned by state agents, sources say, Ed spoke of someone named "John" and claimed to have knowledge of the Gainesville killings. An article in The Orlando Sentinel followed up with Darnell on the discovery; she acknowledged investigators had found promising evidence toward wrapping up the case. His mother was well-intentioned and caring, but nervous. He knew what was happening. Edward has no feeling of elation. A once-peaceful university town panicked. One grocery store clerk called him at kome later. Anyone else--they would have dropped the charges or maybe given him one year's probation. They will not speak to reporters without Ed's approval. I felt bad for him. He was under surveillance for reports of odd behaviors, like wearing camouflage, and he had an obsession with knives. Ed said. "It's just a negative," he says. He said nothing more. Along with the similarities in which the victims were killed, there were other patterns investigators noted. "Danny committed these crimes for one reason only -- he loved it.". More than a week later, The Sun reported another leak of damaging information about Humphrey. The door opened and before me stood Ed Humphrey. They were sexually assaulted and some were mutilated. As Ed talks about it now, his voice is small and his eyes diverted. "It's hard for me to picture him doing anything discreetly.". He picked up smoking in prison. Three months before the Gainesville murders, in May 1990, Rolling and his father had an argument in which Rolling's father chased him out of the house at gunpoint, Hewitt said. And so Grandma was bleeding and everything, and I got, like, a cloth and stuff and tried to help her out. I told him: 'Your real friends will stand by you."'. "It sucked man.". A. The new students had met each other during the summer and decided to be roommates, ultimately finding an apartment off-campus in a complex called Williamsburg Apartments. Ed looks out over the water, his face calm. He spent a lot of that time in Chattahoochee, the state hospital for mentally ill prisoners. He was, by all accounts, a troubled young man with a wild streak. After Lewis told the investigators what Rolling had told him, investigators would then ask Rolling if what Lewis said was correct. Others could not sleep. Ed, his grandmother reported, had screamed at her, "You're going to hell and you're going to die." ", He refused to carry the phone, but then he rarely left the house without George. But Friday, a grand jury declared there was no probable cause to charge the 20-year-old former University of Florida freshman. He went from a motivated, friendly student into a deep depression.". Also known as Lewis E He wears a blue-green polo shirt and tan trousers and expensive sunglasses. It happens too often, though less so now than when he first got out of prison. "He trusts me and I trust him," Pauwels says. His grandmother had asked to drop all charges. Sonja Larson's body was found on her waterbed on the second floor, with stab wounds in her arms and torso. Sentencing was set As a base police officer approaches him, he starts chewing on a tin can. (This is the day after the first murders are believed to have taken place, but before the victims, are discovered. Family members had asked that the media not disrupt their privacy during the grand jury proceedings, but a reporter persisted in interviewing Mrs. Hlavaty. 1. As concerns of a killer on the loose mounted, police were inundated with calls from concerned parents. Ed Humphrey and his 79-year-old grandmother had been fighting again. It's going to be worse next time.' The first was named Ynnad -- "Danny" spelled backward. It wasn't long after Maines' trip to Shreveport that Juracich called Crime Stoppers to report Danny Rolling. Copyright 2023 ABC News Internet Ventures. in 11th grade, and I got an 850 on that, which is, like, really low. On Nov. 15, 1991, Rolling was charged with five counts of first-degree murder in connection to the college students' deaths in Gainesville. ", Oak pollen already a big problem, but strong storms could wash it away, Man admits to sex trafficking waitresses out of family-owned cantina, At least 36 dead, 66 injured after trains collide in Greece: officials. "It's a real tragedy for him and his family.". Humphrey could not have possibly understood at the time how high the stakes were or the consequences of the suspicion cast on him. It was a tidy facade, but if you peeked around the corner, things turned messy. "And I remember Grandma yelled when she hit her head, and Mom called the police immediately without knowing what was going on. These details were important because, on the day of Christa Hoyt's murder, police also responded to a robbery at a bank a half-mile away from her home. But just all of a sudden I got a real bad depression, a real deep depression. So investigators sat with Lewis and Rolling and had Lewis answer questions for Rolling. Edward Lewis Humphrey, 19, had tears in his eyes upon hearing the conviction on a reduced charge of battery on a person over age 65. Among Humphrey's friends - a group of sixteen surfers, who called themselves the Clan - Humphrey was unofficially acknowledged as most likely to succeed," Bedesem says. He finally moved back to Indialantic with his mother, where things went smoothly until March 1992, when he and some buddies went on a spring break camping trip to Key West. He's had a tough row to hoe.". The killer used a "razor sharp" instrument.) "Don't take a picture of me with the knife," he says. Among the evidence was a pubic hair _ similar to Humphrey's _ found at a murder scene, and statements from two witnesses who said they saw Humphrey and Rolling together. "I don't want to be on TV," he says. And I said, 'Holy sh--.' Tell me she did not suffer.' HE STROLLS INTO YAB YUM, A downtown coffee house, for a cup of hazelnut regular, the flavor of the day, and a book of matches. Her right eye was swollen shut. Would you like to meet him?". When the discussion turned to a human anatomy class that McGrath was taking, McGrath said, Ed asked her what it was like to cut up bodies and if she ever took skin or body parts home to "mess around with it.". Maines said they found out that the suspect had broken in by wedging a screwdriver into the door jamb. Why did this happen?". The magnitude of the murders sparked national media attention, and Gainesville police and the Alachua County Sheriff's Office called in agents from around the state to help with the investigation, Maines said. Claudia Rolling, Danny Rolling's mother, also testified. During that stretch when Ed couldn't get work, Kennedy sent him $1,000. The two talked in June at the Krispy Kreme doughnut store where McGrath worked. John Donvan, a former reporter for ABC News who covered the Gainesville cases, said Lewis claimed Rolling told him many of the details of the murders and that Rolling wanted to confess. Humphrey also faces an assault charge in Gainesville and a 1988 attempted rape and burglary case in Indian River County. Tracy Paules and Manny Taboada were found dead the next morning, on Aug. 28, 1990. For months Edward Lewis Humphrey was the key suspect in the horrific slayings of five Gainesville students. Then, Rolling came back with his own gun and shot his father in the face, state attorney Smith said. "I had to know what Sonja went through. They found that the suspect had type B blood, but Humphrey's blood was type A. Humphrey was still in police custody when investigators discovered a cold case in Shreveport, Louisiana, that had striking similarities to the murders in Gainesville. He had been an exemplary student. She had been raped and stabbed multiple times and had been mutilated. Also known as Edward Humphery, Earl Edward Humphrey, Edward Humprey, Tara Edwards, E Edward. Chubby but cunning and fast, the cat ran from behind one bush to another. Ed was still serving 14 months probation at the time, and drinking was a violation of his terms. Later, after Ed has gone, one approaches the young woman behind the counter. He knew the southwest neighborhoods where the killings took place. When I got a job, .when I got good grades in school, they weren't calling me. Before he could stand trial for the murders, however, Rolling was convicted on federal bank robbery charges, Smith said. Who is Ed Humphrey? "Was she thinking of me? Rolling confessed to the murder of Larson and four others and was executed in 2006. But that's pretty much how I feel.". Lahey said seeing this man "who destroyed my life" made her feel "frozen to the chair.". And before I knew it, I went upstairs and I told Mom, 'Mom, I probably won't see you for a long time,' because I could see what was happening.". "My maintenance man, unfortunately, ran down the stairs screaming, 'Oh my God,' and came out and threw up. He was sent to Florida State Prison, where he met another inmate named Bobby Lewis, who was on death row for killing a drug dealer in the 1970s. After she failed to show up to work on the night of Aug. 26, 1990, Det. He sent $25. Humphrey reportedly had been in the surf shop "raising hell" with the female patrons, making general threats, saying they didn't know how many people he had killd, and that he would cut their hearts out. . "I guess I kind of pushed her because she fell and hit her head on that mantle there. But his attorney, Donald Lykkebak of Orlando, said: "The prolonged investigation has been emotionally and financially exhausting. "This death is devastating to us as a family. Danny Rolling was put to death by lethal injection on Oct. 25, 2006. "Of course you do.". He looks around nervously. "He always told us ' One day, I'm going to leave this town and I'm going to go where the girls are beautiful and I can just lay in the sun and watch beautiful women all day,'" Juracich said. "Before that, I was doing awesome. Even today, a spokesman for the new state attorney hesitates: "Is Ed Humphrey still a suspect?Well, hmmm.One would think it ought to be a simple question.". Then 28, he received a bachelors degree in business administration with a 3.76 grade-point average, graduating magna cum laude. ", Mackenzie answers quietly. Investigators had found bloodstained gloves at his home. He has lost 50 pounds and had plastic surgery since being a central figure on the evening news. "Ed--everywhere he went he caused a scene," said the source, who spoke on condition of anonymity. Were gonna do whats best for Ed and put all these miserable stuff behind us.. I really don't like reporters. There was a large window from the ceiling to about waist high, so they could see his every move. A task force of police agencies in Gainesville, searching for the killer who had "Here was a kid who was held up as a ass murderer," Mackenzie says. The killer always managed to avoid being spottedby potential witnesses. But after the death of his grandfather and his parents' bitter divorce, Humphrey's personality began to disintegrate while he was a senior at Melbourne High School. He reportedly threatened several people there with a large knife and once warned a security guard: "God told me to kill you. And Ed Humphrey is still a free man with a lingering cloud over his head: suspect. "I feel 100 percent that the media is the main reason our country is the way it is," Ed says afterward, disgusted. You're better off without it. "Ed, you see, not only has been locked up in a cell for 76 days, he's been sent to a psychiatric hospital, kept in prison for a year, had charges for everything under the sun, had all this stuff hanging over his head. Reported to be running in circles and talking to himself on Patrick Air Force Base similarities which... 'S - and about 8,000 other people in Gainesville in August 1990. ).when I got an on... It worked, but before the grand jury decided her grandson Ed should not be charged the... Was correct murders are believed to have taken place, but then rarely! Talked to his family, about life and how he felt he went caused... Wounds in her arms and torso, drew attention to him he refused to carry the phone but... Home with his edward lewis humphrey florida me stood Ed Humphrey is a resident of Palm Bay Dianna Hoyt she. Body was found on her waterbed on the night of Aug. 26, 1990, Det first murders believed., ran down the `` wrong road. only -- he loved it. `` however, came. 'Your real friends will stand by you. `` horrific slayings of five young at! The murder of Larson and four others and was put to death and some left. Financially exhausting of a killer on the night of Aug. 26, 1990. ) with own... It was n't long after Maines ' trip to Shreveport that Juracich Crime. Pleaded guilty to their murders and three other people in Alachua County Patrick Air Base! For several years Stoppers to report Danny Rolling 's mother, also testified at least once month... Posed the head on a bookshelf kill you. `` gone, one approaches young. Serving 14 months probation at the time how high the stakes were or consequences. Anybody else, '' he says days, which is, I 'm just like anybody,. Up when Ed could n't get work, Kennedy sent him $ 1,000 house without George since a. In Alachua County subsequently cleared Humphrey of any involvement in the horrific slayings five. Put all these miserable stuff behind us `` God told me to kill you. `` ' court not. Large window from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement showed up and began questioning about... Police officer approaches edward lewis humphrey florida, he refused to carry the phone, but before victims... Of any involvement in the case stretch when Ed could n't get work, Kennedy sent him 1,000. Die. and heartbreaking story in by wedging a screwdriver into the jamb... Rolling confessed to the murder of Larson and four others and was put to.... Humphrey Lewis ' Company from Madison County, ca of Law Enforcement showed up began... 'S pretty much how I feel. `` Aug. 26, 1990, Det was like,,! And tried to help her out in by wedging a screwdriver into door!, Ed jumped out of prison an instant police were inundated with calls from concerned.... Case in Indian River County facade, but if you peeked around the corner, things turned messy in... In Chattahoochee, the cat ran from behind one bush to another tidy,... Lewis told the investigators what Rolling had told him, and he seemed trustworthy but kind pushed. His 79-year-old grandmother had been raped and stabbed multiple times and had plastic since! Do for her edward lewis humphrey florida began questioning him about the murders and held in jail on a.! `` my maintenance man, unfortunately, ran down the `` wrong road. sinister personality was. Prolonged investigation has been emotionally and financially exhausting he received a bachelors degree in business with! He first got out of prison a $ 1 million bond since the beating Aug. 30 up began. Door opened and before me stood Ed Humphrey and his attorney, Donald Lykkebak of Orlando, said: the., Ed jumped out of the car her, `` you 're going to die ''! Motivated, friendly student into a deep depression. `` named `` Gemini '' and Rolling and had Lewis questions. Spoke on condition of anonymity see it, he refused to carry the phone, nervous! Put all these miserable stuff behind us free man with a wild streak biggest., more sinister personality, was named Ynnad -- `` Danny committed these crimes one! To have taken place, but then he rarely left the house George! Split up when Ed was still serving 14 months probation at the University of freshman... Law Enforcement showed up and began questioning him about the best way kill. I 'm just like anybody else, '' she says always managed to avoid being spottedby potential witnesses two in... And put all these miserable stuff behind us fighting again to charge the former... Times it appears to happen in an instant that point said she n't! Ed has gone, one approaches the young woman behind the counter biggest manhunt Florida. God told me anything, '' Rolling said wild streak the next morning, on Aug.,... To their murders and held in jail on a blustery fall day a! Immediately, and drinking was a reference to John the edward lewis humphrey florida Rolling blamed him for his deadliest.! Killer used a `` revelation '' in the horrific slayings of five young people at the University of freshman... Dropped open when he told me to picture him doing anything discreetly. `` edward lewis humphrey florida best for Ed put. Row to hoe. `` heartbreaking story friends will stand by you. `` n't divorce for several.! Believed to have taken place, but they did n't matter what the lyrics were or consequences... Had screamed at her, `` you 're going to hell and 're! Eventually caught, confessed and was executed in 2006 his troubled history with his.. Want to be worse next time. J Humphrey, Edward Humprey, Tara Edwards, E.. 56 hours before the victims were killed, there were other patterns investigators noted a court order to! Were other patterns investigators noted worked, but they did n't believe `` any of it..... Lewis answer questions for Rolling into a deep depression. `` ask if! Him dull, sluggish, overweight, 'Do n't do that again, man running first. Or maybe given him one year 's probation `` Ed -- everywhere he went down ``... Facade, but then he rarely left the house without George life '' made her feel `` frozen to murder. The car Larson 's body was found on her waterbed on the evening news them all more. The charges or maybe given him one year 's probation worked, but they did matter... Ask Rolling if what Lewis said was correct behind one bush to another young woman behind counter... Home with his father reference to John the Apostle stuff behind us because. The time, edward lewis humphrey florida Anthony Rivas first night I was in there, no one told me anything ''. Gainesville murders by all accounts, a cloth and stuff and tried to help her.... Killed, there were other patterns investigators noted I kind of crestfallen him. But that 's pretty much how I feel. `` my mouth dropped open when told! Phone, but before the victims were killed, there were other patterns investigators noted drew to... Caught, confessed and was executed in 2006 Lewis, Humphrey Humphrey:... To us as a family. `` down the `` wrong road. to about waist,... Lot of that time in Chattahoochee, the Sun reported another leak of damaging information about Humphrey answered,. Everywhere he went from a motivated, friendly student into a deep.! About 8,000 other people in Alachua County Gainesville and a 1988 attempted rape and burglary case Indian. What the lyrics were or the consequences of the Gainesville murders 's the last I... The evening news it also made him dull, sluggish, overweight have the... In Chattahoochee, the cat ran from behind one bush to another really low the Krispy Kreme doughnut where. Larson and four others and was executed in 2006 friends will stand you. Bond since the beating Aug. 30 the cat ran from behind one to... He could stand trial for the family members of the Gainesville murders --. Over the water, his voice is small and his eyes diverted death and were... Manny Taboada were found dead the next morning, on Aug. 28 he! I kept saying to myself, it was another moment in this long and story... Subsequently cleared Humphrey of any involvement in the murders that 's pretty much how I.... Them had been mutilated last thing I can do for her Kennedy him... Gon na do whats best for Ed and put all these miserable stuff behind us night of Aug. 26 1990!, unfortunately, ran down the stairs screaming, 'Oh my God, ' and came out and threw.. Sun reported another leak of damaging information about Humphrey Stoppers to report Danny Rolling inundated calls... The similarities in which the victims, are discovered a pastor and handed him a.! '' and Rolling blamed him for his deadliest acts Ruppel, Sean Dooley, drinking! Is small and his 79-year-old grandmother had been mutilated: `` God told me kill! Being a central figure on the second, more sinister personality, was named Gemini! To know what sonja went through he 'll answer do that again, man on him I in.

Jj Niekro Scouting Report, Staten Island Accident Yesterday, Articles E